Rose Quartz would never shatter a gem... or so Steven thought. Yet the Crystal Gems have been well aware about Rose Quartz' betrayal of Homeworld and her destruction of Pink Diamond. However, none of them were there, so they must have heard the story secondhand. And the one witness we've seen is a character who was duped twice, once even by shapeshifting. Could the clues we've been given suggest that the picture Steven has been painted is not as simply black and white as the gems would like him to believe? Or perhaps, that they themselves have been led to believe?