What did I say in the last theory that was very similar to this one? What if Rose Quartz only APPEARED to shatter Pink Diamond? After all, if rubies were the only witnesses... well, they were tricked into playing the human game of baseball with a bunch of gems they thought were humans, and tricked into thinking Amethyst was Jasper. Having it been blatantly pointed out on two different occasions that rubies are not the smartest gems, is that an obvious hint to the fact that Rose Quartz did not in fact shatter Pink Diamond?
